A six based solely on attractiveness? On a 1-10 scale? That's crazy. Because a 1 would have to be some sort of retarded wolf-man hairy, disgusting jabba hobbit hybrid creature. While a 10 would be some sort of goddess of all things hawt. She's definitely vastly more attractive than a werejobbitard, and much closer to goddess level. So being about average makes no logical sense either.
I know this shit is mostly just personal preference. But come on, she's much, much hawter than your average chick. Unless you're 1-10 scale is based on very odd preferences. Which, if so, should be stated to avoid any sort of confusion. Like, if we were rating food and you had weird tastes you should say "I'd give bacon a 5. It's nothing special. It should be noted, however, that I enjoy the taste of my own feces straight from my ass." 1-10 scale shouldn't be purely personal preference is what I'm saying here. Otherwise a 10 could be anything from this:
tl;dr- You noobs are fucking up the 1-10 hawtness scale. Knock it off.
Edit: Second pic is an actual ten.