Gee, ur dictating whats Logical and whats not. Im not surprised...
Problem though.. I skimmed through and found this and couldnt help but notice u wrote some good examples of correct logic. However, then u went and presented something I said as Illogical by putting examples that don't even pertain to my original Idea, only the first example.
One would think people would be wiser to avoid such a silly fallacy, but some just seem to love it. Here’s an example:
A Rinnegan user was dubbed the 7th Path
The 7th Realm is a step to reach Buddhahood
Therefore, Rinnegan users can reach Buddhahood
firts example is canon based:
1. The manga states that the RG user (nagato, madara) is the 7th path/pain/realm with the 7th power of Gedo Rinne Tensai.http://www.mangareader.net/93-454-1/...apter-449.html
Thats canon, not some conclusion based on logic or reason.
second example is based off the natural cycle of 10 realms rebirth and is in no way incorrect.http://www.sgi-uk.org/index.php/buddhism/tenworlds
2. "The 7th realm is a step to reach Buddhahood" is true in the beliefs of some Buddhist practices. the 7th realm is on the way to 10 or the 1rst on the way as well with the 4 nobles realms. Its how the realms work. One keeps reaching higher levels until Buddhhood is attained at in the final realm/path/world.
3. RG users can reach buddhahood If, Kishi lets them because its his manga and he can have naruto reach buddahood if he wants because its a fictional story where almost anything can happen.
Whats worse is even without the consideration of kishi having a RG user reach buddahood through the final three paths because its a fictional story and he can do what he wishes.
The Idea is based on logic in the first place.
:The RG wielder is the 7th realm, the first realm of the 4 more noble realms to reaching buddahood.
:the 7th realm is based on,
+ Learning about life and oneself from others and from existing knowledge.
- Can lead to self-centredness and separation from others. In the Lotus Sutra people of Learning and Realization were taught they could only enter the realm of Buddhahood through faith.
Reaching the next realm to buddahood through faith... the same thing nagato finally had after being self centered and trying to bring pain to the world.
"naruto, I will believe in u". Nagato put faith in naruto which is whats required.
:Kishi is clearly basing his realms off of the Buddhist practice of "10 worlds rebirth" as shown by the RG user, 7th realm nagato attaining his level of 7th realm by putting faith in naruto which then allowed him to use the 7th realms ability (Gedo Rinne Tensai).
:By simple deduction of how kishi writes. Kishi powering up his doujutsu after maxing them out like the SG that has had 3 levels now. And kishi already using the 7th realm which is one of the noble realms and part of the 10 realms of rebirth. Its highly likely that kishi could power up the RG 3 more paths to 10, from 7.
Yea, explain to me how thats illogical... Please, I gotta hear this one.