Shrike

Never played Red Dead Redemption, so I can't judge, but Mass Effect? It's an excellent game, but I always end up comparing it to the best RPGs out there, and, well, Mass Effect falls short on Baldur's Gate II. And again, it's a good game, but will never leave a mark for me. It's just sort that feeling : "That was a great game man." And then forget it in a few days.

And Fallout III I can't even take seriously because Fallout II was such an amazing game. Far from it being a bad game, just can't compare to the original. Like playing RE5 after RE1,2,3

Will try out Red Dead Redemption when I have the time. Unfortunately I am a little short on that one. I don't get it how you guys manage to play all those games :/ When you discuss here, most of the games you mention, I have never even heard about.

Oh and Mal, never played Portal, but from what I've heard, it's really a great game.