Fandom Forums - View Single Post

*subrosa* · 05-16-2006, 09:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rasengangt

nice ideas in your post. Obviously, someone is gonna die in the next book cuz "dark lord will rise once more more terrible than before". My guess are a several order members, and of course someone close to harry. Maybe it might be ron, but i think that would be cruel on part of JKR cuz harry has already experienced loss in all forms; his parents, his closest thing to being a father, and now his mentor. But who knows? JKR is good at keeping us guessing, so it could be ron or someone else.

THe horucruxes so far are the ring(destroyed), locket(maybe in grimmauld place), cup, nagini, voldemort himself, something of ravenclaw, and the last one maybe harry himself, cuz he does have that bolt thing on his forehead which looks like the scar on the ring. But honestly i dunt think harry is a horuxcrux, it would make the plot to kill voldemort too complicated. The last guess i would make is the hat, just cuz it symbolizes everything hogwarts stands for.

RAB? My guess is Regulus something Black. From what weve gathered from the first 6 books, no other name works as well. My guess is that JKR Isnt gonna throw in a character whom we havent heard of, so RAB has to be someone we have either encountered or heard about. Even though sirius said his brother was a coward and backed out a week after joining, its most likely sirius didnt look into the details of his brother. For all we know, the reason regulus looked like a coward was because he betrayed voldemort and had to flee. Theres a lot of loopholes in this theory and ill discuss it later if anyone wants to hear about it. Thats my take for now

Well, there seems to be a lot of possibilities in your speculations, can't really say I've got a lot of things I can say to prove that you're wrong... except... if the Hogwarts hat were a Horcrux, anyone who would've touched it would've been cursed, or killed, or whatever, so there wouldn't really be much students left, so I figure this is a bit of a wide guess, I don't think the Hat is a Horcrux, but it might just be that there isn't a 7th Horcrux yet, because he was killed ont he night he wanted to make the seventh Horcrux, so maybe the last one still needs to be made, possible, right?
It could be that Harry and whatever others will have to stop him from making a 7th Horcrux, or wait until he tries, because when he doesn something like that, he might just be vulnerable for a moment and that could be the perfect chance to kill him.

On RAB... you could just be perfectly right, I thought of regulus myself, but because of what was told about him, I didn't expect him to be the one who had taken the Horcrux, but the name really does fit and none of the other names do... Knowing JKR it might just be a new person though, she's suprised us with things like that before... Though, with the end of the books so close in sight, I think it'd be meaningless to enter another new character...

Anyone ever thought of the possibility that this book might have a sad ending? It might just be that the 'good guys' aren't going to win at all, maybe they'll just die or something and Voldie will win... (yeah, but then again, maybe Luna will become powerful and Summon a few of her imaginary mystical beasts... not to insult Luna)
Ah well, I just hope the new book will be there soon^^