Re: Naruto Theory
It's definently not a 'Naruto is the 4th' situation. I proved it wrong when I thought of it myself in another thread. Naruto wouldn't have had to resign the summoning scroll if that were so.
Orochimaru attempted to summon the 4th. As for him being dead, err, the summoning could've possibly failed anyways. Like, it comes up, and nothing's there, sort of thing.
I can only imagine that Jiraiya would be the only one who'd know for sure if Yondaime was dead or alive. I think he's dead, and was Naruto's father. I prefer to let the man rest in peace.