the_fat_alchemist

OK. I just want to see people's opinions on this matter. I belive that the tomes in Sharingan each have a different use. For example. One tome, slows down movement and allows the user to copy movement. Upon mastering the Sharingan, the user is able to copy handseals as Kakashi did against Zabuza and predict movement before it happens as Sasuke does in the Valley of the End. The second tome gives the user a chakra sense of sorts. Basically what Sasuke does in the Forest of Death. It allows the user to see the chakra signature of a person. When Sasuke uses this in the Forest of Death it shows him that none of the Rain nins are there and that Naruto is fighting Bunshins. This would also explain how Itachi knew that Sasuke was behind him when he and Kisame went to capture Naruto. The third tome allows the user to better control, see through, and counter Genjutsu. This is compareable to when Itachi counters Kurenai's Genjutsu when he and Kisame return to Konoha. Kakashi also used something like this when he was in Tsukuyomi. I think Kakashi couldn't break Tsukuyomi because Mangekyou Sharingan is a higher level of Sharingan, and therefore casts obviously stronger Genjutsu.
That's all on Sharingan.

Byakugan sort of ties in with this. If one tome of the Sharingan gives the user a chakra sense then that would explain why it is theorized that Sharingan comes from Byakugan. The Sharingan has other special traits that make it stand out. This is why, if the Hyuugas and Uchihas are realated, the chakra sense is dulled from the Byakugan. Byakugan allows the user to view the Tenketsus and chakra circulatory system. If the Sharingan could do that it would never be defeated. So to make the Sharingan different from the Byakugan, it has the abilities I listed above. Sharingan and Byakugan are similar because they both have a chakra sense. It is more refined in the Byakugan because that is Byakugan's main purpose. Sharingan's main purpose is different. Thus the dulling of the chakra sense. When Byakugan is active, vains form around the eyes. Why is that? I think that it's the constant chakra pumped to the eyes to maintain it's abilities. But if that's the case why doesn't Sharingan have the same vains? They both require a constant feed of chakra to keep them active. But why does one show vains, and the other doesn't? My thought is that to have the Sharingan show vains would make it too apparent that the Sharingan is derived from Byakugan. I don't know how...Maybe a Hyuuga had an afair with an woman outside the clan. The child that was born did not have Byakugan but a weak Sharingan and the family was outcast. Possibly the defaint Hyuuga was slain and the mother escaped with the child and changes her name to avoid being sought out by the Hyuugas. Later on down the line two Uchiha cousins have a child and thus the true Sharingan is born. It keeps going like that until a somewhat large clan is born. The clan winds up in Konoha, and the Hyuuga's threaten war. So to avert a crisis, the current Hokage, creates a seperate village inside Konoha for the Uchiha clan. Thus, the Uchiha clan that Sasuke and Itachi were born into.


Now I know this seems farfetched but bear with me. This is my belief and I'm interested to hear opinions, comments, or suggestions. Just don't come here simply to flame this. I wouldn't go to you opinion and flame it....Even Constructive critisim is welcome.

__________________


http://www.myspace.com/blackruto"

Akatsuki Shinobi

interesting beyond beleif!!!!!!!!!!

__________________




proud member of The Geijutsuka Crew (TGC)

Smeeeeee

great theory but the thing about byakugan is that u cant tell upon the evolution and development of it. eveyone looks like they all have the ability to use byakugan. unlike the sharingan where only a certain few can use it

__________________

Akatsuki Shinobi

byukugan has been handed down to all in the hyuga famaily, unlike the sharingan, that was only passed down to a majority, but not all.

__________________




proud member of The Geijutsuka Crew (TGC)

narutoeye

excellent theory, but i think u should post this in anime section, so more people can read it and give their comments.

__________________

the above pic is from episode 1 when naruto said: I'm going to surpass all the previous hokages and then I'll make the village recognize my strength.

Mr. Papaya

Wouldn't it make more sense for the 3rd tome to be the one that allows the user to predict movement? The first time we see Sasuke predicting movement is when he fights Naruto in the Valley of the End, right after he develops the 3rd tome.

hyuuga hiroyuki

thats what i was gonna say...exellent theory but u got the sharingan levels the wrong way round ^^
sasuke gets the 3rd tome when fighting naruto in the valley of the end and then he realise's that he can suddenly predict narutos movements alot faster and learned how to counter them, and his first tome allowed him to see chakra

__________________

beautiful-green-beast

I believe that when the user activates Byakugen, veins form around there eyes because members of the Hyuuga Family don't have pupils. Remember, the sharingan only appears in the user's pupils, opposed to Byakugan, which uses the entire eye. Thus forces the Byakugen to work harder, and this probably leads to what you were saying, Alchemist, about how the veins show the constant flow of chakra. Since, I'm guessing, the Byukagen works harder in order to forcefully create a pupil.

__________________

"The world will look up and shout 'Save us'.
And I'll whisper...no."